BENCHTESTS

Many claims are being made about the latest LED tubes – not least for their efficiency. So we decided to subject one to our famous Lux benchtest. Ray Molony reports

A few years back, the LED tube was the form factor everyone loved to hate. All the big lamp companies were briefing against them: they were inefficient, they had terrible light distributions, they didn’t last 10 minutes.They were also dangerous: some had terminals that would go live when the other end was inserted into a luminaire. Also, why did we need them when we had a perfectly good option: the good old T5?

In short, the LED tube was an LED development too far.

But the tsunami of Chinese products showed there was a market for the category – and all the big lamp companies have now unveiled their own versions. Osram was first to break ranks, revealing its T8 LED at Light + Building in Frankfurt last year. Now they all have them.

The cost – about £40 – is obscene compared with £1.50 for a T5, but the manufacturers believe they can tell a good story about maintenance and life. Maybe.

Creating the market

It’s been the Chinese who have created and developed the LED tube market. So we decided to test one of the best ones we could find. We chose a 28W version, made in China but developed by a Dublin-based engineering company, Lita Lighting.

Originally a Spanish company, Lita Lighting is headed by entrepreneur Sean Carthy, who believes that the LED takeover of the T5 market will be rapid: ‘In 10 years there won’t be fluorescent. There won’t be incandescent. It will all be LED.’

The results from the LED tube are extremely impressive: the lamp delivered a whopping 2,732 lumens, and a luminous efficacy of 98lm/W, just a whisker shy of the magic 100lm/W metric. This more than matches a high efficiency T5 lamp with a rated efficacy of 104lm/W.

So far so good. Sure, this is a stonking performance, measured in strict conditions, but efficacy isn’t everything. The thing to remember is that LED tubes aren’t direct replacements for fluorescent lamps. So don’t even think of putting them into a luminaire designed for fluorescent. Fluorescents have true omnidirectional distributions, but LED are directional sources, and it takes a lot of optics to change this. Still, LED tubes will have their place – especially if their performance is as good as ones like this.

 

HOW WE DID THE TESTS

The benchtest took place at Lux magazine’s official test house, the highly respected laboratories of 42 Partners in Wolverhampton. The tests were conducted in a 3.5m integrating sphere, one of the largest in the UK, and all measurements were taken in accordance with EN13032 and performed with the lamp in a horizontal, LEDs-down orientation. The lamp was treated as a luminaire with the LED cluster treated as an integral part. The photometric centre of the luminaire was taken as the geometric centre of the cover and the photometric nadir was taken to be perpendicular to the front face of the cover. The luminaire has been treated as though it has two planes of symmetry through the 0°/180° plane and the 90°/270° plane.
No measurement of the absolute lumen output of the LED cluster or of individual LEDs separate from the lamp assembly was made. For calculation purposes, the lumen output figure should be used in conjunction with a LOR of 1. No measurement of the ballast factor of the control gear was made.
The lumen output and power consumption of the lamp was determined at 25°C after 100 hours of burn-in.
42 Partners
21 Woden Road
Wolverhampton
WV10 0AU
UK
Tel: +44(0)1902 453650
richard@42partners.com ian@42partners.com

 

POWER 28W
OUTPUT 2,732 lumens
EFFICACY 98lm/W CRI: >70Ra
NOMINAL LIFE 50,000 hours
DIMENSIONS L 1,500 x W 25 x H 25mm
OUR VERDICT ★★★

One of the best LED tubes we’ve come across. Well designed and engineered, and with a stonking efficacy that almost hits the magic 100lm/W. But think carefully, because this isn’t a direct replacement for fluorescent.

RELATED
What the Victorians did for us…

…was give us awkward wrappers in which to put state-of-the-art LED engines. But one Oldham-based manufacturer of heritage lanterns has successfully fused Victoriana with the latest in solid state lighting technology. Ray Molony reports

RELATED
LED challenges the 2D

Zeta Controls has developed an LED version of the 2D lamp – but how does it compare to its fluorescent equivalent? Lux benchtested a sample to find out…